Is "Cancel Culture" a Threat to Free Speech? Many argue that cancel culture has gone too far, leading to the silencing of unpopular opinions or voices. But is it really a violation of free speech or a consequence of people holding others accountable?

Last Updated: 02.07.2025 00:48

Is "Cancel Culture" a Threat to Free Speech? Many argue that cancel culture has gone too far, leading to the silencing of unpopular opinions or voices. But is it really a violation of free speech or a consequence of people holding others accountable?

When speech from “in-groups” is criticized and challenged, you outcry “cancel culture.”

Cancel culture is the “Parental Rights in Education Act” and “Stop W.O.K.E.” Act (yes, that’s a real law being passed in Florida in 2022) that left school libraries with empty bookshelves because every book has to be “evaluated” so the LGBTQ+ content and actual history of United States won’t “traumatize” our children.

On top of that, editors started to caution writers to tone down the LGBTQ+ content if they wanted to get traditionally published. They frame it as “pragmatism,” as in “I’m not here to argue right or wrong. I’m here to help you get published. Do you want to get traditionally published? Then don’t write queer characters.”

Can a hoodoo or candle spell be used to remove a love spell placed on someone by another person? What is the difference between voodoo and hoodoo?

I’m a writer. All of my stories feature minority and LGBTQ+ characters. I follow many BookTok creators on TikTok, editors, writers, readers… etc. Upon Trump’s election, “keep politics out of books” had gone viral. Many BookTok content creators made videos about how they don’t want politics in their books and that books are escapism. Except, of course, all books are political. All art is political. So when people say “I don’t want politics in my book/movie/video games,” what they are really saying “I don’t want books/movies/video games to challenge my existing political views.” After all, even the most conservative players have no problem with games in which ally soldiers fight against Nazis when anti-fascism is inherently political.

Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition …There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect.

This is the moment I’m reminded of the Wilhoit’s Law:

Apple’s leaked 45W MagSafe charger is first to support Qi2.2 - The Verge

That’s what cancel culture looks like: you can’t write, read, or discuss <insert a group of marginalized people and their experiences> or you’ll never get published, your voice is never heard, even if you get published, your books will be removed and banned.

Cancel culture is “Moms for Liberty” waging a war against LGBTQ+ inclusive books.

Cancel culture is when Dixie Chicks criticized Bush’s war effort and was promptly blacklisted by every country music station. It took them over a decade and a name change to come back.

Apple’s 16GB 15-inch M4 MacBook Air now starting from new all-time low at $188 off, more from $837 - 9to5Toys

Cancel culture is the national archive preemptively removed some of the “darker history” of America (such as the civil rights movement or Japanese internment camps) in one of their most recent exhibitions to preemptively appease the new administration. → National Archives Museum Under Fire | Artnet News

When speech from “out-groups” is limited and silenced, you call it “state law.”

Cancel culture is when Sinéad O'Connor criticized the Catholic Church for shielding child rapists, and the backlash promptly ended her musical career.

Why do boobs of some girls bounce when they walk?

The same applies to your interpretation of the cancel culture.

Have you heard of the Hays Code - Wikipedia?

McCarthy-era persecution and silencing of artists, writers, and moviemakers is cancel culture.

Where can Ukrainians go if they cannot have shelter and heating this winter?

Hays Code is cancel culture.

Yes. Cancel Culture is a threat to Free Speech, but not the kind you imagined. Let me explain.

Cancel culture isn’t “people block me online because I say gay people should not get married.” Cancel culture isn’t “Ciri is the next Witcher? The gaming industry gets woke! Men are canceled in video games!” Cancel culture isn’t comedians got some social backlash for saying racist things, not when they turn around and get another Netflix special.

How do I remove the music from a movie or animation? I want to keep the audio from the dialogue and sound effects, but remove the music so that I can add my own.